Hero Backdrop

Insurance case law update: three key judgments for insurers in autumn 2026

Autumn 2026 sees a raft of new insurance-related court judgments, with a win, loss and a draw for insurers

Published on:
Reading time: 5 minutes read

WIN! - Limits of the Third Parties (Rights Against Insurers) Act 2010

The Third Parties (Rights Against Insurers) Act 2010 (“the 2010 Act”) has been in force for a decade now. It was introduced in August 2016 to replace the 1930 Act which was widely criticised for being too insurer friendly. So, the 2010 Act sought to modernise and simplify the law, making it easier for third party claimants to bring claims against the insurers of policyholders who had become insolvent.

The 2010 Act did not purport to completely remove insurers’ rights to use policy terms as a defence to liability – which they would have had against the insured had it not gone insolvent – but questions remained as to what limits there were in practice.

Makin v Protec Security Group Ltd (October 2026) is one of the few English court judgments on the 2010 Act. The Court of Appeal was asked to review a first instance decision in insurers’ favour where it was decided that the insured (Protec) had failed to promptly notify a claim against it by Mr Makin in accordance with the terms of a public liability policy issued by QBE. So, QBE validly denied liability.

The claimant (who had suffered a stroke a short time after an altercation with Protec’s door staff at a restaurant) argued that the Judge had been wrong to find that Protec had breached the notification provisions – which were poorly drafted and not expressed to be conditions precedent to QBE’s liability.

Whilst commenting that the drafting was “verging on the chaotic” and that QBE only had an ‘entitlement’ to refuse an indemnity if timely notice was not given, the Court of Appeal nevertheless upheld the original decision and found that the clauses were conditions precedent which Protec had breached.

So, the case confirms insurers’ ability to rely on notification provisions – even poorly drafted ones – to defeat claims under the 2010 Act.

LOSE! - Obligation to provide D&O defence costs in fraud/bribery cases

Less happily for insurers, the court in Liberty Managing Agency Ltd v Chedid (September 2026) found that the D&O underwriters for the large oil and gas services company Petrofac were obliged to pay substantial defence costs of two individuals in relation to criminal proceedings against them.

The two defendants had been charged with bribery and had already burned through a primary and first excess layer (of £15 million each) on legal fees defending themselves. The claimants – second excess layer insurers – sought a declaration that they were not liable for a potential further £15 million in defence costs. This was on two main grounds: first, that the policy had been validly avoided for fraudulent misrepresentation/non-disclosure, alternatively that such defence costs are uninsurable as a matter of public policy. Second, that the costs of defending bribery allegations are also uninsurable as a matter of public policy.

On the first ground, the relevant clause was:

“8.2 The Insurer shall not avoid this policy…on the grounds of misrepresentation or non-disclosure, except with respect to:

1. an Insured who has fraudulently misrepresented or fraudulently non-disclosed material information prior to the conclusion of this contract; …

where such fraudulent conduct is established by a final decision of a court, tribunal or regulator or by a formal written admission of the Insured."

The court had no difficulty finding that fraud had to have been proven (or admitted by the insured) before insurers could avoid the policy. Insurers alternative argument was a more novel point. It stemmed from the general English law principle that someone cannot benefit from their own deliberate wrongdoing and insurers maintained that payment of defence costs in the present circumstances amounted to exactly that, even where the fraud had not yet been proven. The Judge disagreed and held that there was nothing in English law which precluded parties from contractually agreeing what would happen if fraud were proven, which is what the clause does.

On the second defence (concerning bribery), the Judge found that – by a reference to an employment (i.e. a non-insurance) case arising from the News of the World phone-hacking scandal – there was no public policy prohibition on paying someone’s reasonable defence costs of any judicial proceedings.

So, if D&O insurers suspect that their policy was obtained fraudulently they should take steps to prove it as quickly as they can but, until they do, they should expect to have to pay their insured’s defence costs, regardless of what they have been accused of.

DRAW! - Business interruption/Broker’s negligence

Cases on business interruption (BI) clauses are pretty rare, but Camstar Herbs Ltd v Advisory Insurance Brokers Ltd (October 2026) is a recent one. It’s also unusual for the way in which insurers sided with the insured, against the broker.

Camstar is “the largest producer of dried parsley in the world, outside China”. Historically, it had bought the “gross revenue” form of BI policy. At renewal the defendant broker, Advisory, recommended a new, cheaper, policy with a different insurer, which Camstar accepted. However, Advisory had unwittingly obtained a “gross profit” form of BI policy which was much narrower in scope.

Following a fire at its premises, Camstar made various payments to its suppliers so that they would be in a position to continue supplying it with parsley once the factory was repaired. It had expected that the payments would be covered under the Increased Cost of Working (ICOW) part of its BI cover. However, insurers explained that such payments would not be covered under the ICOW in the “gross profit” BI (but would have been under a “gross revenue” policy).

Camstar accepted that and turned its fire on the broker – suing Advisory for negligently failing to obtain cover suitable for its needs. One of the defences raised by Advisory was that the ICOW clause in the “gross profit” policy did cover the payments, such that Camstar in fact had a valid claim against insurers. Camstar had therefore caused its own loss by not making that claim. However, Advisory did not attempt to join insurers into the proceedings, which might well be expected if that were its position.

However, insurers were involved in the trial in that – in a very unusual turn of events – their appointed adjuster (a renowned BI specialist) ended up giving expert evidence in the insured’s favour. The insured also had its own BI expert.

Perhaps unsurprisingly in the circumstances, the Judge analysed the ICOW clause in the “gross profit” policy and determined that it did not cover Camstar’s payments to the suppliers, therefore Camstar had no valid claim against its insurers. Instead, Advisory’s negligent failure to recommend an appropriate policy had caused the loss and thus the broker was liable.

So, a good outcome for the BI insurers, less so for the broker’s E&O carriers.

How can Weightmans help?

Our specialist insurance lawyers provide practical advice on policy coverage, claims disputes and complex insurance litigation. Contact our team to discuss how we can support your business.

Insurance law

Did you find this article useful?