Hero Backdrop

On the right track? Rail employment in a devolved UK

“The railway is an extraordinary institution. People who work in this industry are hugely committed, and I know for many of you like me it's a vocation.” These are the words of Rail Minister Lord Hendy addressing delegates at November’s Rail Industry Association Conference. As the sector enters a new era of reform, how will greater regional control reshape employment across the railway—and what will it mean for the people whose livelihoods it directly or indirectly supports?

Published on:
Reading time: 5 minutes read

Since July 2024’s General Election eleven passenger rail companies have been transferred into public ownership, and five more (Chiltern, Great Western, East Midlands, Avanti West Coast and CrossCountry) due to switch this autumn, which taken as a whole accounts for nearly 64,000 employees (it should be noted that freight providers have not been included in this wholesale shift), plus approximately 42,000 currently working for Network Rail.    

So, as well as HR departments referencing TUPE guidance, what has this meant for drivers, conductors, station staff and other roles? The launch of Great British Railways (GBR) – on an as yet unspecific date next year – will be significant in reshaping the future workforce, particularly the integration of train and track teams under a single directing organisation, which theoretically will result in a more co-ordinated approach encountering fewer organisational boundaries, clearer operational authorities and faster escalation during times of disruption.  

However, the cross-cutting devolution agenda may – if not sensitively handled – lead to overlapping territories and possibly uneven levels of service between neighbouring areas (although this was arguably also a feature of the pre-devolution era). This could theoretically mean services running later in some areas than others, or a myriad of other variations in working patterns depending on the appetite of Combined Authorities and other ecosystem decision-making bodies.  

The key question is to what extent can terms and conditions be standardised if operational decisions are increasingly devolved? Only time and events will really tell… 

Personal terms for staff 

Whilst there are unknown elements as GBR formulates, there are aspects of its Statutory Terms and Duties which provide some clarity. Firstly, the Railways Bill does not create a statutory workforce settlement – there is no proscription of headcount, pay, hours, roles or grades. However, it does create:  

  • a statutory mechanism for transferring existing staff and employment liabilities into the new organisation

  • broad operational, passenger, safety, efficiency and public-interest duties that will influence workforce decisions indirectly; and  

  • a framework within which future headcount, restructuring and working practices will be determined through ministerial direction, GBR management decisions, funding settlements and collective bargaining. 

GBR will employ approximately 90,000 staff according to minister for logistics Keir Mather, and a ‘resourcing model’ will be designed to ensure it is an ‘agile and efficient public service, and we will continue to engage on our plans and the impact on staff’. Indeed, the initial consultation was held between February and April 2025, and ‘Shadow Great British Railways’ was established in September 2026 to integrate leaders, specialists and other senior stakeholders to manage the transitional phase. 

In general, TUPE restricts contractual changes where the sole or principal reason is the transfer itself, so granular changes to legacy contracts would presumably be conducted over a much more prolonged period.  

However, there has been a mixed response from the unions, simultaneously welcoming the creation of GBR whilst criticising the lack of certainty around employment structures and elements such as standardised collective bargaining and bolstered conditionality around pay and conditions. There has been particular consternation from the RMT and ASLEF regarding £3.9 billion efficiency savings for the period 2024-2029, with up to 2,000 lower-tier management roles at risk of cuts. Some industry figures argue that total headcount should be increased, not decreased given current circumstances. 

The productivity, capacity and safety triangle 

It would seem an increase in headcount would be required given projected growth metrics, at least in terms of modernisation of track, signalling, infrastructure and rolling stock as well as an ambitious electrification/decarbonisation project AND a steady increase in passenger numbers.  

It is a moot question as to whether enhanced technology could deliver required levels of health and safety the across the network as well as capacity increases with current/reduced numbers of employees. To borrow from Steve Jones of industry group Railfuture when considering public ownership transfer in the East Midlands – “the devil is in the detail’, and so it will be nationwide. Better coordination and integration of the network is within reach, as is an employment scenario agreeable to all major stakeholders but is by no means guaranteed.  

Unresolved issues 

The formation of GBR and issues around devolution are by no means the only points of contention, with various stakeholders debating aspects of a variety of issues such as: 

  • Workforce deployment: staffing levels, driver-only operation, ticket offices, rostering and rest days 

  • Workforce transformation: technology, changing roles and skills requirements 

  • Employment model: outsourcing, pay comparability, maintenance arrangements and depot rationalisation 

Furthermore, there are demographic factors to wrestle with in the existing workforce, for example less that 4% of train drivers are under 30, and less that 12% are women. Also, according to government figures a quarter of existing employees will reach retirement age by 2030. In response the DfT launched a recruitment ‘driver drive’ among young people on August’s GCSE results day, and the minimum age requirement was reduced from 20 to 18 in June.  Alongside this, the government has announced 600 rail foundation apprenticeships over the next four years, with another 450 expected to be employed at GBR’s new Derby HQ.

Freight workforce cannot be overlooked 

Despite the freight operators and their employees staying resolutely within the private sector, freight is a central pillar of industrial strategy and encompasses at least an extra 10,000 workers. There is a government target to increase rail freight by at least 40% by 2040.  

This mandated target alone suggests rapid job creation across the sector in the near to medium future, as it will need substantially more headcount to successfully transfer an estimated £15 billion of goods from road to rail annually.  

Concluding – GBR has multiple substantial issues to deal with 

As with other issues around devolution and rewiring/reinvigorating the state, GBR needs to deal with an array of arguably conflicting issues at once, such as being expected to: 

  • improve efficiency 

  • accommodate passenger and freight growth 

  • modernise infrastructure 

  • maintain or improve safety 

  • deal with an ageing workforce 

No matter who is making the decisions or paying the wages, it will not make these underlying, unresolved tensions disappear. Hopefully, burgeoning structural/organisational changes coming down the track will make it easier to resolve them.  

Did you find this article useful?