Hero Backdrop

Operational Dishonesty – Administrative Court rules that there is presumption of dismissal

Published on:
Reading time: 2 minutes read

Executive Summary

Two officers were found to have committed gross misconduct involving an allegation of operational dishonesty. They were not dismissed and received a final written warning. The Chief Constable challenged the panel’s decision by way of judicial review. The Chief Constable claimed that the panel erred in law in failing to apply the legally required approach to operational dishonesty. The College of Policing Guidance on outcome applies that law and raises a presumption of dismissal for acts of operational dishonesty. The Administrative Court agreed and quashed the decision of the panel and passed the matter back to the panel for reconsideration of the sanction.

The facts

The following facts were admitted and led to a finding of gross misconduct. On 23 - 24 March 2024, a 9mm ammunition round for a Glock 17 pistol went missing during officers PC Cornes and PC McRobb’s shift at MDP Donnington, which they were aware of when they went off duty. The 9mm round was missing from PC McRobb’s magazine. PC Cornes and/or PC McRobb failed to: (i) record that a round was missing; or (ii) report the round was missing to the oncoming officers, line management or the control room. PC Cornes made the following declaration in the Firearms Log Book which he knew to be inaccurate: “I mustered all weapons and ammunition and being correct handed over the keys to the armoury”. PC McRobb declared that he had returned 30 rounds in the Firearms Logbook and omitted to record that one round was missing.

The College of Policing Guidance, applying the principles in Salter v Chief Constable of Dorset [2012] EWCA Civ 1047 states at Paragraph 5.4, ‘The proper approach to cases involving operational dishonesty, derived from the case of Salter, can be summarised as follows: [a] dismissal will be almost inevitable in cases where operational dishonesty has been found proven; [b] there may be exceptions but the number of such cases will be very small; [c] where the person(s) conducting the proceedings concludes that a case involving operational dishonesty falls into this very small residual category, they must identify the features of the case that render it exceptional’. The Court accepted this guidance because it reflected the law as stated in Salter.

The court found that despite recognising that this was a matter of operational dishonesty the Panel failed to record or indicate any recognition of any principle that operational dishonesty will usually result in dismissal or make any reference to the relevant section in the College of Policing Guidance on outcome. The court accordingly found that the Court had erred in law, found for the Claimant and quashed the panel’s decision.

Comment

The decision reinforces the presumption of dismissal for operational dishonesty and the need for panels to apply the College of Policing guidance on outcomes. The individual facts of the case reinforce this principle. Ministry of Defence Police require strict control of firearms and ammunition given their role and the fact that they routinely carry these arms. The College of Policing Guidance applies to MOD Police despite the fact that their regulations sit outside the statutory framework for Home Office force.

For guidance on dealing with operational dishonesty within the police force, please contact our expert police misconduct solicitors.

Did you find this article useful?

Written by:

John Riddell

John Riddell

Partner

John specialises in police and public work. John and his team cover all areas of police law ranging from litigation to operational advice and police discipline.

Related Sectors: